1. GST: going concern on a development site
Questions
Is the supply a GST-free supply of a going concern?
Answers
No.
Facts
A property developer bought a development lot under a contract accompanied by a future obligations deed. After the purchase, it carried out preliminary work: town planning, engineering and design, site clearing, and the erection of construction sheds. Before construction began, it agreed to sell the lot to a buyer who would complete the shopping centre development. The contract recorded the parties’ agreement that the sale was a supply of a going concern.
Explanation
The conditions: A supply of a going concern is GST-free only if the supplier provides all of the things necessary for the continued operation of an enterprise, and carries on that enterprise until the day of the supply. Goods and Services Tax Ruling GSTR 2002/5 adds that the parties’ own description of the transaction is not conclusive; the circumstances are examined objectively.
The identified enterprise: Following the Federal Court in Aurora Developments, the enterprise must first be identified as particular activities with content, not merely an objective. Until the content of the enterprise is isolated, it is not possible to say whether all necessary things were supplied.
Operation versus commencement: GSTR 2002/5 distinguishes carrying on an enterprise, which includes commencement and termination activities, from operating one. An enterprise that is only being commenced is not yet capable of being handed over in a state where the buyer could carry it on. Preliminary development activities, such as planning, design and site preparation, are commencement activities, not the operation of a development enterprise.
Applied here, the Tax Office disagreed with the developer’s submission. The sale was merely the sale of an asset, being land prepared for further development. The developer had not carried on an enterprise until the day of the supply, and had not supplied all things necessary for the continued operation of such an enterprise.
Implications
The going concern clause in the contract was not conclusive. The test is objective, and it failed here on both conditions.
For development sites, the line the ruling draws is between commencement and operation. Planning, design, approvals and site preparation sit on the commencement side. The main consequence here is that where going concern treatment fails, the sale is taxable, and the parties must look to the margin scheme or another concession instead. That changes the numbers for both sides and should be resolved before the contract, not after.