1. Capital gains: legal and beneficial ownership of a property
Questions
Will capital gains tax (CGT) event A1 occur on the proposed transfer of the property?
Answers
Yes.
Facts
A couple were the trustees of a discretionary family trust. A parent entered into a contract of sale for a property and paid the deposit, because the couple were interstate at the time of the auction. Before settlement, the parent nominated the couple’s newly incorporated company as purchaser in its capacity as corporate trustee of the trust, and the property was registered in the company’s name alone.
The couple paid the transfer duty from their joint personal account, made payments to the company, funded repayments through an equity access loan in their own names, and reported the net rental income on their individual returns on a 50:50 basis.
They later retired as trustees in favour of a trustee company. The parents refinanced the property in their own names. The company holding the title was deregistered by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission for an unpaid review fee and later re-registered.
The existing dwelling was demolished (a parent signed the demolition contract as or on behalf of the owner), and the couple incurred the construction costs of a new dwelling and assisted with its construction and project management. They moved in as their main residence and paid all outgoings.
They now propose to execute a deed of acknowledgment stating that the company has held the property on trust for their sole benefit since acquisition, transfer the legal title to themselves as joint tenants, and then voluntarily deregister the company.
Explanation
CGT event A1 arises when a change of ownership of a CGT asset occurs (sections 102-20 and 104-10 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997). Working out whether a change of ownership occurs starts with legal ownership, and the legal owner is the person recorded on the title.
Taxation Ruling TR 93/32 sets out the Tax Office’s view where the equitable interest in a property may not follow the legal title. Consistent with paragraph 41 of that ruling, the edited advice considers that the legal and equitable interests diverge only in extremely limited circumstances, and that there must be sufficient evidence to establish that the equitable interest differs from the legal title. That evidence must be a contemporaneous written record made at the time of acquisition, showing that the legal owner holds the property on trust for the beneficial owner.
A trust may be express, constructive, or resulting. An express trust over land requires certainty of intention, subject matter and object, and must be evidenced in writing. A constructive trust is imposed by operation of law when equity considers it unconscionable for the person holding title to deny another’s interest; its existence depends on a court order. A resulting trust may be presumed where the legal title does not reflect the parties’ contributions to the purchase price, as in Calverley v Green [1984] HCA 81, where a trust is presumed in favour of the party providing the purchase money.
Section 106-50 treats a beneficiary who is absolutely entitled to a CGT asset as against the trustee as owning the asset. Draft Taxation Ruling TR 2004/D25 takes the view that the records must be in writing and must clearly state the assets to which a beneficiary is entitled for their own benefit to the exclusion of the other beneficiaries; it also observes that an indivisible asset cannot satisfy the claims of beneficiaries with shared interests. In the absence of a record of allocation, it would be reasonable to conclude that shared interests in the trust assets, by their nature, prevent absolute entitlement.
Applied here, the reasons record that the trust deed was varied to appoint the company as trustee and that the variation was prima facie stamped by the State Revenue Office, and that stamping, together with the actions taken to make the company the registered proprietor, showed the couple knew they were placing the property under the trust. The stated facts do not record a deed of variation; they record a deed of appointment and retirement of trustee made after settlement. The edited advice did not examine whether the trust was validly constituted, treating the trustees’ compliance with their fiduciary duties as a matter between the trustee and the beneficiaries.
There was no contemporaneous record of how the property was to be attributed between the two of them: whether equally, in some other proportion, as joint tenants or as tenants in common. It is not enough to state after the event that both were absolutely entitled. The proposed deed of acknowledgment, being a document created after the purchase, does not satisfy the record-keeping requirement; the edited advice treated documents that are not contemporaneous with the acquisition as not influential in supporting a beneficial interest different from the registered legal title. CGT event A1 will therefore occur when the company transfers the property.
Implications
A client who has always treated a property as theirs, having paid the duty, serviced the loan, declared the rent, rebuilt the house and lived in it, can still fail to displace the legal title. The edited advice concluded that the couple were not absolutely entitled to the property as against the trustee, and that no contemporaneous evidence supported a beneficial interest different from the registered legal title. It did not apply a resulting or constructive trust analysis to the facts. Its bottom line is that conduct of that kind does not substitute for a contemporaneous written record.
In practice, document the arrangement at acquisition. Where a nominee or trustee purchases, the trust or beneficial ownership documentation must exist at the time of purchase and state how the asset is held and for whom.