Articles / Edited private advice
Weekly Private Advice · Issue #7

Subdividing on capital account, and a foreign fund's exemption

Five lots sold out of a long held investment property, and the gains stayed under CGT. Plus a foreign super fund that pays no withholding tax on its Australian dividends.

Written by
Andrew Lovett
Andrew Lovett
Founder, Tony.Online
3 November 2026 · 8 min read

About this series: We go through the edited private advice the Australian Tax Office publishes, select the most relevant and set out what it means. Each one records the Commissioner’s decision for a single taxpayer on a single set of facts, so it shows you the approach rather than giving you authority to rely on. Each summary carries its authorisation number. Andrew’s full disclaimer is at the foot of this article.

A yellow tracked excavator standing on bare ground beside a road, with the sun setting behind it
★  Advice of the week

1. Property development: subdividing surplus land held as a long-term investment

Authorisation 1052543329375 · 1 June 2026 · edited private advice

Questions

Will any part of the profit on the sales of five lots subdivided from a long-held investment property be assessable income under section 6-5 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997?

Will any part of the profit on the sale of a sixth lot, sold with a seventh in a single transaction, be assessable income under section 6-5?

Answers

No. The sales are mere realisations of capital assets, and the gains are subject to capital gains tax (CGT) under subsection 104-10(4).

No.

Facts

The trustee bought a property with buildings to hold for long-term capital growth and commercial rental income. It was always recorded as a single asset held on capital account and leased to tenants for many years.

The trustee later registered a multi-stage subdivision to sell land that was surplus to the leasing operations. Two stages progressed, yielding six lots; a seventh lot with buildings made up the balance. Engineers, surveyors, contractors and a real estate agent did all the subdivision work, planning and selling, and the trustee took a passive role. It borrowed nothing, entered into no development agreement, and did only the works the council required. Five lots sold to unrelated parties to free up capital for maintaining and improving the buildings, which remain leased to long-term tenants.

The trustee proposes to sell the remaining two lots at market value to a new company owned and controlled by the next generation of the family. The family group includes separate entities that develop residential property for resale as a business; the trust has always been a standalone structure with its own purpose and funding.

Explanation

A profit on a sale of land is ordinary income under section 6-5 if the taxpayer carried on a business of land development, or if the sale was an isolated or commercial transaction entered into with the intention of making a profit. Otherwise it is statutory income under the CGT provisions in Parts 3-1 and 3-3. Taxation Ruling TR 92/3 sets out the Tax Office view on isolated transactions.

Miscellaneous Taxation Ruling MT 2006/1 (paragraphs 264 to 266) lists factors from the farm subdivision cases: a change of purpose for which the land is held; extra land acquired; the land brought to account as a business asset; a coherent plan of subdivision; a business organisation; borrowed funds; interest claimed as a business expense; development beyond what council approval requires; and buildings erected. No single factor decides the question.

In Commissioner of Taxation v Morton [2026] FCAFC 31, the Full Federal Court held that a retired farmer whose farmland was subdivided and sold as housing allotments under a development agreement had neither carried on a business of developing land nor ventured the land into a profit-making scheme. The agreement did not make the developer’s business the taxpayer’s business, and the scale of the project did not weigh either way.

In Re FLZY and Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2016] AATA 348, a family group ran development and long-term investment side by side. The Tribunal rejected the Commissioner’s characterisation of the group as carrying on one business of property acquisition, development and disposal: each property had been allocated to a discrete activity, and the property sold was earmarked at acquisition as a rental investment.

The edited advice concluded the sales were mere realisations. It relied on the intention at purchase and the lack of change at subdivision, the long holding, the absence of borrowing, works limited to council requirements, and no buildings erected. Each disposal is CGT event A1 (section 104-10), and the gain is the excess of capital proceeds over the cost base (subsection 104-10(4)).

Implications

For a client subdividing part of a long-held investment property, the whole of the facts settles the character, and the file has to show them. The facts that were decisive here and in Morton: intention at acquisition, no change of purpose, no borrowings, no development agreement, a passive principal, and works limited to council requirements.

In practice, you could build the evidence at the start of the engagement rather than at the sale: record the purpose for holding the land, keep the council requirements on file, and document the reason for selling. A sale to free up capital for maintaining retained buildings reads differently from a sale made to capture a profit.

Where the family also runs a genuine development business, you could keep the entities, funding and activities separate, as the family did here and as the group did in Re FLZY. Blurred lines invite the Commissioner to treat the group as one development business.

Also this week

One more piece of edited private advice. Open it for the answer and the reasoning.

02

2. Withholding tax: foreign super fund exemption on Australian investment income

Authorisation 1052544229149 · 2 June 2026 · edited private advice

Questions

Is the Fund excluded from liability to withholding tax on the interest, dividend and non-share dividend income derived from its Australian investments under paragraph 128B(3)(jb) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936?

Show the answer and reasoning

Answers

Yes.

Facts

The Fund is a superannuation fund established in a foreign country and administered under that country’s laws, and it is exempt from income tax there. It was established and is maintained to pay retirement, disability and death benefits to members who are not Australian residents. Its central management and control is carried on outside Australia by entities that are not Australian residents. No amount paid to the Fund can be deducted under Australian tax law, and no tax offset is allowable for amounts paid to it or set aside for it.

The Fund holds ASX-listed investments and derives interest, dividends and non-share dividends from them. Its total participation interest in each investee is below 10%. It has no board or committee appointment rights, no side letters or similar arrangements, no veto rights, and no capacity to influence the day-to-day management of its investees.

Explanation

Section 128B of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 imposes withholding tax on dividends and interest derived by non-residents (subsections 128B(1) and (2)). Subsection 128B(3) excludes prescribed categories of income. Paragraph 128B(3)(jb) excludes interest, and dividends and non-share dividends paid by an Australian resident company, derived by a non-resident that is a superannuation fund for foreign residents and exempt from income tax in its country of residence.

Section 118-520 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 defines the term. The fund must be an indefinitely continuing provident, benefit, superannuation or retirement fund, established in a foreign country, and established and maintained only to provide benefits for individuals who are not Australian residents. Its central management and control must be carried on outside Australia by non-resident entities. A fund fails the definition if contributions to it have been or can be deducted, or a tax offset allowed, under Australian tax law.

The edited advice states that the Fund met the definition and was exempt from income tax in its home country, so the conditions of paragraph 128B(3)(jb) were satisfied.

Subsection 128B(3CA), inserted by the Treasury Laws Amendment (Making Sure Foreign Investors Pay Their Fair Share of Tax in Australia and Other Measures) Act 2019, adds three further conditions for income derived from 1 July 2019. The fund must satisfy the portfolio interest test in subsection 128B(3CC): its total participation interest in the payer must be less than 10% when the income is derived and throughout any 12-month period in the prior 24 months ending by that time.

The fund must not have influence of the kind described in subsection 128B(3CD): it must not be able, alone or in concert with others, to determine who makes the decisions that control and direct the entity’s operations, and no such decision-maker may be accustomed or obliged to act on the fund’s wishes. The income must not be non-assessable non-exempt income of the fund under Subdivision 880-C of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 or Division 880 of the Income Tax (Transitional Provisions) Act 1997.

The edited advice states that all three were met. Each holding was below 10%. The Fund held no appointment or veto rights and no side letters, and its only voting rights were in proportion to its equity interest, so it had no influence of the relevant kind. The income was not non-assessable non-exempt under Subdivision 880-C or the transitional provisions. Under section 128D, income on which withholding tax would be payable but for paragraph 128B(3)(jb) is not assessable income and not exempt income.

Implications

The exemption is not automatic. A foreign super fund client with Australian portfolio income needs its status confirmed against each condition before the exemption is assumed: the foreign-resident fund definition, tax exemption in the home country, holdings below 10% in each investee, and no influence rights.

The influence test reaches beyond shareholding size. Board appointment rights, committee seats, veto rights and side letters all go to it. On the edited advice’s facts, ordinary voting rights in proportion to the equity holding did not amount to influence. In practice, the statement the Fund gave about its status is the kind of evidence to keep on file for a fund claiming this exemption.

The conditions have to be kept. The portfolio interest test is measured when the income is derived and across a prior 12-month period, so you could watch any holding that drifts toward 10%, including drift caused by a buy-back or capital return.

Disclaimer: We believe this information is correct at the time of publication. It is general in nature, for guidance only, and is not intended as personal advice. It should not be relied upon without professional advice about your direct circumstances. No responsibility can be accepted by any publisher, author, editor, contributor, or consultant for loss directly or indirectly arising from any person acting or refraining from acting wholly or partly upon the material in this publication, or for any error, broken link, or omission from the publication. Edited private advice is published by the Tax Office in modified form. It is based on private rulings that apply only to the taxpayer who applied. It is not a public ruling and cannot be relied upon by another taxpayer. This publication is general information for Australian tax professionals only; it is not tax, financial, or legal advice. It is not suitable for other people.

Andrew Lovett
Written by
Andrew Lovett
Founder, Tony.Online · Director, Lovetts · Registered Tax Agent

Two decades working across every entity type, and a computer-science background that turned into Tony.Online, the tireless second analysis he always wished he had.

More reading

View all →

Get the advice every week.

The week’s ATO edited private advice, easy to read. One email, every Tuesday. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.