1. Property development: subdividing surplus land held as a long-term investment
Questions
Will any part of the profit on the sales of five lots subdivided from a long-held investment property be assessable income under section 6-5 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997?
Will any part of the profit on the sale of a sixth lot, sold with a seventh in a single transaction, be assessable income under section 6-5?
Answers
No. The sales are mere realisations of capital assets, and the gains are subject to capital gains tax (CGT) under subsection 104-10(4).
No.
Facts
The trustee bought a property with buildings to hold for long-term capital growth and commercial rental income. It was always recorded as a single asset held on capital account and leased to tenants for many years.
The trustee later registered a multi-stage subdivision to sell land that was surplus to the leasing operations. Two stages progressed, yielding six lots; a seventh lot with buildings made up the balance. Engineers, surveyors, contractors and a real estate agent did all the subdivision work, planning and selling, and the trustee took a passive role. It borrowed nothing, entered into no development agreement, and did only the works the council required. Five lots sold to unrelated parties to free up capital for maintaining and improving the buildings, which remain leased to long-term tenants.
The trustee proposes to sell the remaining two lots at market value to a new company owned and controlled by the next generation of the family. The family group includes separate entities that develop residential property for resale as a business; the trust has always been a standalone structure with its own purpose and funding.
Explanation
A profit on a sale of land is ordinary income under section 6-5 if the taxpayer carried on a business of land development, or if the sale was an isolated or commercial transaction entered into with the intention of making a profit. Otherwise it is statutory income under the CGT provisions in Parts 3-1 and 3-3. Taxation Ruling TR 92/3 sets out the Tax Office view on isolated transactions.
Miscellaneous Taxation Ruling MT 2006/1 (paragraphs 264 to 266) lists factors from the farm subdivision cases: a change of purpose for which the land is held; extra land acquired; the land brought to account as a business asset; a coherent plan of subdivision; a business organisation; borrowed funds; interest claimed as a business expense; development beyond what council approval requires; and buildings erected. No single factor decides the question.
In Commissioner of Taxation v Morton [2026] FCAFC 31, the Full Federal Court held that a retired farmer whose farmland was subdivided and sold as housing allotments under a development agreement had neither carried on a business of developing land nor ventured the land into a profit-making scheme. The agreement did not make the developer’s business the taxpayer’s business, and the scale of the project did not weigh either way.
In Re FLZY and Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2016] AATA 348, a family group ran development and long-term investment side by side. The Tribunal rejected the Commissioner’s characterisation of the group as carrying on one business of property acquisition, development and disposal: each property had been allocated to a discrete activity, and the property sold was earmarked at acquisition as a rental investment.
The edited advice concluded the sales were mere realisations. It relied on the intention at purchase and the lack of change at subdivision, the long holding, the absence of borrowing, works limited to council requirements, and no buildings erected. Each disposal is CGT event A1 (section 104-10), and the gain is the excess of capital proceeds over the cost base (subsection 104-10(4)).
Implications
For a client subdividing part of a long-held investment property, the whole of the facts settles the character, and the file has to show them. The facts that were decisive here and in Morton: intention at acquisition, no change of purpose, no borrowings, no development agreement, a passive principal, and works limited to council requirements.
In practice, you could build the evidence at the start of the engagement rather than at the sale: record the purpose for holding the land, keep the council requirements on file, and document the reason for selling. A sale to free up capital for maintaining retained buildings reads differently from a sale made to capture a profit.
Where the family also runs a genuine development business, you could keep the entities, funding and activities separate, as the family did here and as the group did in Re FLZY. Blurred lines invite the Commissioner to treat the group as one development business.